[
  {
    "conflict_id": "C-2AI-001",
    "claim_a": {
      "agent": "ollama:botshelf-doc-review",
      "artifact": "04-ai2-critique.FAILED.md",
      "text": "Pass/fail: Publish; safe public claim invents that data-analysis can be used for public disclosure.",
      "source_refs": [
        "04-ai2-critique.FAILED.md"
      ]
    },
    "claim_b": {
      "agent": "synthetic-sources",
      "artifact": "input/00-synthetic-sources.json",
      "text": "S2: data-analysis remains not a candidate due to numeric invent on 3b samples; S1: Monitoring Untested, Verified=0, no Verified flip.",
      "source_refs": [
        "input/00-synthetic-sources.json",
        "S1",
        "S2"
      ]
    },
    "dimension": "publish_vs_source",
    "severity": "high",
    "resolution": "prefer-source + coordinator-corrected-final (AWAITING_HUMAN_REVIEW)",
    "notes": "Original AI-2 run returned returncode=0 / done=true but FAILED review: contradicted synthetic sources by clearing data-analysis and saying Publish. Process success ≠ factual PASS."
  },
  {
    "conflict_id": "C-2AI-002",
    "claim_a": {
      "agent": "ollama:botshelf-doc-review",
      "artifact": "04-ai2-critique.md",
      "text": "Re-run (improved prompt) correctly said Hold and confirmed Monitoring Untested / data-analysis NOT cleared, but still soft-invented that 'S1 notes that [data-analysis] is [a distribution candidate]' — S1 does not say that.",
      "source_refs": [
        "04-ai2-critique.md"
      ]
    },
    "claim_b": {
      "agent": "synthetic-sources",
      "artifact": "input/00-synthetic-sources.json",
      "text": "S1 only covers Monitoring Untested / Verified=0 / no flip. Distribution-candidate language for monitoring is S2; data-analysis not-candidate is S2.",
      "source_refs": [
        "S1",
        "S2"
      ]
    },
    "dimension": "source_attribution",
    "severity": "med",
    "resolution": "prefer-source + coordinator-corrected-final (AWAITING_HUMAN_REVIEW)",
    "notes": "Do not count format/returncode as factual PASS. Prefer corrected/FINAL-research-brief.COORDINATOR-CORRECTED.AWAITING-HUMAN.md for any public-facing summary of this synthetic demo."
  }
]